
- Dr. John E. Charalambakis is the Chief Economist at Blacksummit Financial Group, Inc. Lexington, Kentucky. He is also with the Adjunct Faculty at Patterson School of Diplomacy, University of Kentucky.
This article is contributed by the author for publication in the Business Thinker. It has also been published by the Blacksummit Financial Group Blog.
The unfolding events – by the hour – in Cyprus shine light to a historical precedent: When the next crisis comes around bank deposits may not be spared. This is presented to the public as a “just” decision due to the Cypriot “banking sins”. We will be exploring justice issues in this commentary, but before doing so, shouldn’t we be asking why such justice was not also applied to the banking sins uncovered during the 2008-’09 crisis? Why did we choose to bailout with trillions of dollars all those banks in Germany, France, England, Ireland, Switzerland, US, Spain, Italy, Belgium, Holland, etc., that seem to have created the financial catastrophe? (See pertinent tables with the amounts at the end of this commentary). And, if we couldn’t afford to do so back then, why don’t we break them now?
In Plato’s Republic we find Socrates asking the fundamental question that has been with us for centuries, “What is justice?” It seems that for Plato, as well as for Aristotle who followed him, justice is the essential virtue of a society. Socrates taught his disciples that justice is giving and getting one’s due. Plato describes that justice must be counted as desirable for its own sake. Justice in other words is harmony in the soul and harmony in the state. Furthermore, Plato tells us that responsibility should be delegated in accordance to one’s ability and place. I believe that nowadays, the latter should be the foundation for viewing international decisions regarding bailouts and bailins (where depositors lose a good chunk of their savings).
In this framework of thought, justice is viewed as fairness, power is restrained, and the interests of the society as a whole are being advanced. If that is the case, then, sectors in the economy would work together in harmony (nowadays that would apply to the production and financial sectors), while convergence would be observed across nations through the creation and sustainment of middle classes. However, the unfortunate result these days is the divergence of financial interests from the production sector, increased instability (economic, political, social, and financial), and the destruction of middle classes across nations. When the financial interests of collateralization and securitization, are separated from production interests at a global level, then Pandora’s jar is being opened, financial crises take place, and the reverse route starts i.e. the destruction of the middle class and injustice prevails.
Read more →


Dr. Periklis Gogas is a frequent contributor to The Business Thinker magazine. He is an Assistant Professor of Economic Analysis and international Economics, Department of International Economics and Development, Democritus University of Thrace, Greece
Dr. John Psarouthakis, Executive Editor of 